If you or someone you know is struggling with depression and medications haven’t worked, or if you’re looking for a treatment option with fewer side effects, you may have heard of two alternatives: transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). Both treatments have shown promise for those dealing with severe or treatment-resistant depression; however, they work in very different ways and come with their own set of considerations. When it comes to deciding between TMS vs. ECT, having a better understanding of the differences between the two can help you choose the best treatment that’s right for you.
TMS is a noninvasive treatment that involves placing a magnetic coil near the scalp to deliver pulses to stimulate nerve cells. Unlike more invasive procedures, TMS doesn’t require anesthesia, incisions, or electrical currents passed directly into the brain. The treatment is FDA-approved for depression and is typically recommended for those who haven’t responded well to traditional depression treatments like antidepressants or talk therapy.
While TMS is generally considered safe, some side effects can occur, though they are usually mild and temporary. The most commonly reported side effect is a headache that may be experienced during or shortly after a session. This happens because the magnetic pulses can stimulate the muscles in the scalp. Another frequent side effect is scalp pain or discomfort at the site where the coil is placed, which can occur during the treatment itself.
Here are other potential side effects to keep in mind:
TMS can be a beneficial treatment for those with specific needs and circumstances. It’s often a good fit for individuals with mild to moderate depression who are looking to minimize disruption to their daily routines. Because TMS doesn’t require medication, it may appeal to those who have experienced adverse side effects with traditional antidepressants or have found other treatments too intense or ineffective.
ECT is a medical treatment that is used mainly for severe depression and other serious mental health conditions. During the procedure, a brief electrical current is passed through the brain while the patient is under anesthesia which causes a controlled seizure. A team of medical professionals, including a psychiatrist and anesthesiologist, oversee the process to make sure the patient is safe.
Though ECT has been around since 1938, its techniques and safety measures have greatly improved since then. It’s often considered when other treatments, like medication and therapy, haven’t worked.
While ECT can be effective, it does come with a range of side effects that vary in intensity and duration. While some are mild and temporary, others may require closer monitoring. Side effects may include:
ECT could be the best option for those facing severe, hard-to-treat depression or when a person needs quick relief due to a crisis. It’s often reserved for individuals who haven’t found success with other treatments.
Deciding whether TMS or ECT is the better treatment depends on a person’s unique needs and circumstances. Both are effective for major depression, but each one differs in how they work, intensity, and side effects. TMS is a less invasive option for moderate cases or when other treatments haven’t worked. In contrast, ECT is more invasive but can be a better option for those with severe, treatment-resistant depression. Let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of each.
TMS is known for its noninvasiveness and safety with fewer side effects than many antidepressants, making it a good option for people who want to avoid drug-related side effects. However, the treatment requires a significant time commitment with multiple weekly sessions for several weeks. Access to TMS can also be limited by insurance coverage.
Benefits and potential drawbacks of TMS include:
On the other hand, ECT is often chosen for severe depression cases. It tends to produce quicker results, sometimes within just a few sessions. However, ECT comes with a higher likelihood of side effects, such as temporary memory loss, and requires a recovery period.
Pros and potential cons of ECT include:
Switching between TMS and ECT is generally considered safe, but it should be done under the supervision of a qualified mental health professional. Both treatments target the brain differently, and individual responses can vary. For example, if someone experiences significant side effects from ECT, they may find TMS to be a gentler option.
When considering a switch, it’s important to discuss the potential risks and benefits with your healthcare provider. Things like current symptoms, treatment history, and overall health should be evaluated. Your provider will monitor the transition while looking for any adverse reactions, adjusting schedules, and managing side effects.
Choosing between TMS vs. ECT is a big decision, but you don’t have to make it alone. Consult with a mental health provider to discuss your symptoms, treatment history, and personal preferences. They can guide you toward the best option for your needs and help you weigh the potential benefits and risks of each treatment.
Determining if TMS therapy suits your mental health journey should involve consultation with a qualified professional. At Cura Behavioral Health, we provide comprehensive assessments to help you make informed treatment decisions.
Don’t let a mental health condition hold you back any longer. Schedule a consultation with Cura Behavioral Health today. Our experienced team is ready to answer your questions and create a personalized treatment plan tailored to your unique needs.
Join our newsletter to stay up to date on features and releases.
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.
Dr. Kevin Simonson, an esteemed Medical Director at Cura Behavioral Health, brings over 15 years of experience in psychiatry. A graduate from a top medical school, he specializes in the treatment of mood disorders and anxiety, employing a patient-centered approach. His dedication to evidence-based care and his commitment to advancing mental health practices have made him a respected figure in the field. Dr. Simonson’s leadership ensures the highest standard of care for the community at Cura Behavioral Health.
